View our latest offers
Track My Order My Profile Beauty Blog Help
BROWSE ALL
Accessories & Tools (169)
BB Value Picks (60)
Body (353)
Father's Day (27)
Fragrance (172)
Body Mist (17)
Candles (49)
Diffusers (80)
Perfume & Cologne (37)
Men (1)
Women (32)
Room Spray (7)
Hair (2640)
Halloween (251)
Holiday 2025 (83)
K Beauty (31)
Kids & Baby (126)
Makeup (3024)
Makeup Brushes (136)
Makeup Remover & Wipes (33)
Men (197)
Nails (235)
Pets (8)
Professional Makeup Artist Tools (55)
Refills (45)
Sets & Gifts (151)
SFX Makeup (332)
Skincare (701)
Wellness (123)
Makeup Eye Makeup Brows Pencils

Shop Pencils

Sort by featured Sort by newness Sort by average rating Sort by price: low to high Sort by price: high to low
Eyebrow pencils help to fill and define your brows. Available in thicker, softer formulas for bold l...Read more ooks - through to super fine-tipped formulas that help create more definition and natural looks with the appearance of individual hair strokes.
Sort by featured Sort by newness Sort by average rating Sort by price: low to high Sort by price: high to low
Filter products +
Dual Brow Perfect Dual Brow Perfect
Eye of Horus Dual Brow Perfect
13 reviews
$43.00 AUD
OFFER: Free lipstick when you spend $49 with Eye of Horus*
  In stock - Ships tomorrow
Brow Define Brow Define
Eye of Horus Brow Define
10 reviews
$39.00 AUD
OFFER: Free lipstick when you spend $49 with Eye of Horus*
  In stock - Ships tomorrow
Hi-Def Brow Pencil Hi-Def Brow Pencil
RevitaLash Hi-Def Brow Pencil
$51.00 AUD
  In stock - Ships tomorrow
Great Brows Now, Pay Later
Shady Slim Brow Pencil Shady Slim Brow Pencil
LA Girl Shady Slim Brow Pencil
40 reviews
$11.95 $9.56 AUD
ON SALE
  In stock - Ships tomorrow
Eyebrow Pencil Eyebrow Pencil
Australis Eyebrow Pencil
14 reviews
$11.13 AUD
  In stock - Ships tomorrow
Micro Brow Pencil Micro Brow Pencil
1000 Hour Micro Brow Pencil
$11.78 AUD
  In stock - Ships tomorrow
Kind & Free Brow Definer Kind & Free Brow Definer
Rimmel London Kind & Free Brow Definer
$18.44 AUD
  In stock - Ships tomorrow
Ultimate Brow Retractable Ultimate Brow Retractable
Wet n Wild Ultimate Brow Retractable
13 reviews
$11.56 AUD
OFFER: Free gift when you spend $49 on Wet n Wild*
  In stock - Ships tomorrow
Brow Saber Eyebrow Shaping Pencil Brow Saber Eyebrow Shaping Pencil
LA Girl Brow Saber Eyebrow Shaping Pencil
$17.56 $14.05 AUD
ON SALE
  In stock - Ships tomorrow
XtendBrows Shape & Sculpt Pencil - Light/Medium XtendBrows Shape & Sculpt Pencil - Light/Medium
MCoBeauty XtendBrows Shape & Sculpt Pencil - Light/Medium
$17.82 $10.69 AUD
SALE: Save $7.13
  In stock - Ships tomorrow
XtendBrows Shape & Sculpt Pencil - Medium/Dark XtendBrows Shape & Sculpt Pencil - Medium/Dark
MCoBeauty XtendBrows Shape & Sculpt Pencil - Medium/Dark
$17.82 $10.69 AUD
SALE: Save $7.13
  In stock - Ships tomorrow
Brow-Sessive Brow Pencil Brow-Sessive Brow Pencil
Wet n Wild Brow-Sessive Brow Pencil
2 reviews
$8.86 AUD
OFFER: Free gift when you spend $49 on Wet n Wild*
  In stock - Ships tomorrow
Imitations Micro Brow Pencil Imitations Micro Brow Pencil
Brow Code Imitations Micro Brow Pencil
$44.96 AUD
  In stock - Ships tomorrow
3-In-1 Brow Pencil 3-In-1 Brow Pencil
1000 Hour 3-In-1 Brow Pencil
$18.15 AUD
  In stock - Ships tomorrow
Featherlite Brow Shaping Powder Pencil Featherlite Brow Shaping Powder Pencil
LA Girl Featherlite Brow Shaping Powder Pencil
5 reviews
$15.73 $12.58 AUD
ON SALE
  In stock - Ships tomorrow
Eyebrow Pencil
Ben Nye Eyebrow Pencil
$16.96 AUD
OFFER: Free Gift when you spend $89 on Ben Nye*
  In stock - Ships tomorrow
Everyday Perfect Brow Pencil - Medium/Dark Everyday Perfect Brow Pencil - Medium/Dark
MCoBeauty Everyday Perfect Brow Pencil - Medium/Dark
$19.38 $11.63 AUD
SALE: Save $7.75
  In stock - Ships tomorrow
Tattoo Brow 36HR Eyebrow Pencil Tattoo Brow 36HR Eyebrow Pencil
Maybelline Tattoo Brow 36HR Eyebrow Pencil
$20.46 AUD
  In stock - Ships tomorrow
Brow Designer Pencil Brow Designer Pencil
Sorry, sold out
Join Waitlist
essence Brow Designer Pencil
$3.67 AUD

Recent reviews in Pencils

Contour Pencil - Lake 910

Kryolan

Contour Pencil - Lake 910
Quality eyeliner

This eyeliner is amazing, it has a smooth application and the color is super pigmented. I definitely recommend to all and will be purchasing again :)

- Renee
Shady Slim Brow Pencil - Black

LA Girl

Shady Slim Brow Pencil - Black
Best affordable thin brow liner

This is the best quality price-wise I’ve found for a pencil thin enough to draw individual brow hairs. Comparable to Benefit’s Precisely My Brow.

- Tamari
Shady Slim Brow Pencil - Espresso

LA Girl

Shady Slim Brow Pencil - Espresso
Perfect

Great shade!

- Georgia

JOIN OUR MAILING LIST: